Invoice disputes: Common causes and how to resolve them
Consider a wholesale seafood distributor that receives a $4,400 payment against a $4,800 invoice sent to a restaurant. The customer leaves a payment note: $400 deduction due to 10 cases missing.
The distributor’s accounts receivable (AR) records still show $400 outstanding. But the customer isn’t saying they won’t pay or requesting time to pay. They are questioning the quantity billed.
This is the textbook case of an invoice dispute. Now, the AR team will evaluate the invoice against the purchase order and proof of delivery. What we thought was an overdue balance may require investigation involving multiple teams.
But the good news is that such invoice disputes are recognizable. But to distinguish them from other invoice issues, you should understand what causes them.
What is an invoice dispute?
An invoice dispute arises when the buyer/customer disagrees with an invoice’s charges or payment terms. The customer may request clarification or ask the vendor to revisit the payment terms before approving the payment.
An overdue invoice is one that remains unpaid after its due date. However, this doesn’t necessarily mean the customer disputes the amount owed. Disputed invoices require a different approach to handling overdue invoices.
The AR team must understand the objection, evaluate it against supporting records, and coordinate with relevant teams to arrive at a resolution.
What are the common causes of invoice disputes?
Invoice disputes often begin when customers don’t see what they owe the vendors. Sometimes, it’s a billing mistake. Sometimes, the customer questions whether the invoice meets their agreed payment terms.
While the payment terms stay confidential between the customer and the vendor, let’s explore some of the common reasons for invoice disputes:
1) Incorrect pricing or discounts
The sales team sells a product or service at a seasonal discount (say, like 10%). However, the invoice doesn’t reflect that. Even if the product or service is up to the mark, the customer may dispute the difference until the agreed discount is applied.
Most often, such invoice discrepancies occur due to miscommunication between teams. In this case, there seems to be zero communication between the sales team and the billing team.
But how to avoid this? Ask the sales team to document agreed discounts in the CRM. This ensures the billing team has the updated pricing before generating the invoice.
2) Quantity and delivery discrepancies
A manufacturer receives an order for 500 components but ships only 400. The manufacturer schedules delivery of the remaining 100 for the following week. However, the customer receives an invoice for all 500 components.
The customer may question why they’re billed for the entire order when part of the shipment is still pending delivery. If the agreed payment terms require billing after delivery, this mismatch can lead to an invoice dispute.
Such discrepancies when shipping and billing teams operate in silos. While the shipping team knows that part of the order is still pending, the billing team may have already generated the invoice for the entire order.
3) Product quality or incomplete services
The invoice for $6,000 lands in a client’s inbox after a software development company marks the project complete. However, the client responds: some of the features we agreed on are missing.
The development team believes the milestone is complete because progress updates were shared throughout the project. However, the client argues that certain features still don’t meet the acceptance criteria outlined in the contract.
Such disputes continue to impact invoices until the service provider and the client agree on what qualifies as completed work.
The business impact of disputed invoices: 4 key statistics
An invoice dispute puts the AR teams orbiting around investigating the issue, coordinating with other departments, and following up with the client/customer. While the dispute takes time to resolve, the outstanding amount may continue to affect cash flow.
But what kind of impact does this have on businesses? Here are the key statistics that put the problem into perspective:
- In research commissioned by the UK Department for Business and Trade, 31% of surveyed businesses cited invoice disputes as a reason for paying their suppliers late.
- In the 2025 Groceries Code Adjudicator survey, 9% of UK grocery suppliers reported delayed or missing payments involving disagreements over deliveries.
- According to FCIB’s Credit & Collections Survey, 65% of respondents identified billing disputes as a cause of payment delays involving U.S. customers.
- American Express’s 2026 Trendex survey found that 61% of surveyed U.S. financial decision-makers agreed that employees spend too much time resolving invoice- or payment-related issues.
These numbers show why invoice dispute management needs more than just routine follow-ups. But how should AR teams resolve them before they further delay collections?
How to resolve invoice disputes: A step-by-step process
Step 1: Understand and document the dispute
The first step AR teams need to take is to understand exactly what the customer/client is questioning. Is this about a specific charge or an entire invoice?
The team should document the invoice number, disputed amount, customer’s explanation, and any information they’ve shared. This becomes increasingly helpful when managing AR aging. Not every invoice needs the same approach: one set needs a payment reminder, while several require investigation.
Documenting these details helps relevant teams pitch in instead of contacting the customer for repeated information.
Step 2: Verify supporting records
Documented details should be verified against available business records, such as purchase orders, contracts, and other relevant documents. The objective here is to check what was agreed upon, what’s been delivered, and whether the invoice reflects the same. This verification step gives AR teams a factual basis for invoice dispute resolution.
Step 3: Investigate the concerned teams
This is where other departments come in. If the customer raises a delivery-related issue, input from the warehouse or logistics team may suffice. If the customer disputes the pricing, then the sales and billing teams come in. The objective in this step is to seek help from other teams to establish whether the customer’s claim is valid.
Step 4: Implement the resolution
Based on conversations with other teams, the next step is to implement the ideal resolution. If the customer’s claim is valid, the billing team may need to revise the invoice. If the original invoice is accurate, then the AR team should clarify the customer with supporting evidence. Either way, clear communication is the bellwether of invoice dispute management.
Step 5: Update records and follow-up
Knowing how to handle a disputed invoice doesn’t end with collecting the payment. The AR team should update the records to reflect any changes in payment terms. If there is an outstanding balance, the team can follow best practices for unpaid invoice follow-ups to remind customers about payment expectations.
Conclusion
Sending another reminder will only aggravate the invoice dispute. AR teams should look beyond the outstanding balance and understand what’s causing the disagreement.
When AR teams document disputes, investigate the underlying reasons, and communicate their findings, they can keep collections moving without compromising customer relationships.
A clear invoice dispute resolution process helps businesses address these issues and resume payment follow-ups once the dispute is resolved.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Continuing to send payment reminders without addressing the invoice dispute can irate the customer. However, any undisputed balance requires follow-up as per the agreed payment terms and company policy.
Yes. A customer may discover a billing discrepancy after paying. The business should treat the dispute as they would treat an unpaid invoice dispute. If the dispute is justified, the resolution can be a refund or credit toward a future invoice.
The AR team should first verify the payment details to verify the missing amount. If the reason remains unclear, contact the customer/client to ensure whether the deduction is because of pricing, delivery, a pending credit, or another issue.
Straightforward invoice errors can be resolved within a few business days, while disputes involving delivery discrepancies, service quality, or contractual disagreements can take several weeks. In fact, APQC's benchmarking data reports a median of 4 calendar days to resolve an invoice error. This is not a benchmark for all B2B invoice disputes, though!
